Don’t forget we moved!
https://brandmu.day/
An Arx Peeve Thread
-
@Herja said in An Arx Peeve Thread:
I sort of wish that people would stop making that insinuation that staff would ever permit or GM a story in which children are killed. Repeatedly. Despite staff being very clear as to the boundary regarding that sort of story.
Honestly, I fuck this up sometimes without intent. Men, women and children rolls off the tongue rather absent-mindedly when describing a broad toll of casualties, and it’s a phrase I need to stop using.
-
There is a lot of games that also say that ‘children dying’ is part of war/ a part of a dark setting/etc. Same with things like abuse. So, it could just be hold over.
-
Yeah, that’s certainly part of it. Too many grimdark settings in the past has not improved my writing’s muscle memory, but I certainly don’t enjoy when I mess up and make someone feel uncomfy, either.
-
It’s not that bad things aren’t going to happen to children because war, but the narrative insistence on child involvement when staff has repeatedly said hey we’re not doing that anymore is pretty frustrating.
let it be a challenge to you
-
Oh, certainly. I don’t know the circumstances of the peeve, so I more was lamenting my own fallibility and occasional accidental slips.
-
@sao said in An Arx Peeve Thread:
It’s not that bad things aren’t going to happen to children because war, but the narrative insistence on child involvement when staff has repeatedly said hey we’re not doing that anymore is pretty frustrating.
Basically this.
Personally, I don’t really care about someone talking about kids dying/being hurt as a part of normal RP, like that’s not something that bothers me on an individual non-staff RPer level, but it gets exhausting when folks keep asking staff specifics or to address it directly.
I discovered my line real fast when folks wanted to do stuff or pitch plots in which kids being hurt and/or killed was the entire thing, particularly when it was players wanting their PCs to be the ones doing it. I’m not GMing Child!Hostel: The Torturers are the Main Characters Now.
-
-
-
@kalakh oh damn, I think I remember exactly what you are talking about, lol. I feel like players fall on a spectrum between being so uninvested in NPCs that genocide is fine and being so invested in them that we are having to field uncomfortable questions about NPCs and situations involving them. I feel like being too far on either end of that spectrum is trouble.
-
Well, that took a rather unexpected turn from what I was expecting, what in the actual hell.
-
Idea - do the nautical/aircraft thing and replace ‘men, women, and children’ line with ‘souls’, because it ups the edge factor further. How many people died in the attack? One-hundred thirty-eight souls were killed’.
As for people who want to genocide or murder kids that like… are more than just a ‘my REAL WORLD child is annoying me today, I must vent’ (which… fair), City of Hope WyrmSphere is right over there, and… I dunno if there is a Star Wars game where they can do Empire things, actually. Obligatory plug for a new FFG game or something.
Mummy Pun? MUMMY PUN!
She/her -
@Jennkryst said in An Arx Peeve Thread:
h ‘souls’, because it ups the edge factor further. How many people died in the attack? One-hundred thirty-eight souls were killed’.
Oh, I really like that switch.
-
For me, this kind of thing gives me flashbacks to Firan and the Kinslayer War when Steph did world emits of the royal children being slaughtered in their cradles. It was overly graphic and horrendous and to this day I see no value in how staff relished in the portrayal of it. I’m more than happy that Arx staff have drawn a line.
-
Yeah. ~Firan~.
-
@Solstice said in An Arx Peeve Thread:
Well, that took a rather unexpected turn from what I was expecting, what in the actual hell.
Makes you long for the days of our lost youth, when edgelord villainy consisted of inappropriate cackling, drinking blood from a skull, and trading in infectious cannibalism wine.
-
Yes, really, anything that sounds like it wasn’t pitched by Anakin Skywalker shortly before he went to “visit the younglings”.
-
-
@Solstice Just waiting for the Clone Wars game where I can be a Jedi with a crisis of conscience over how we just up and murdered a whole army of droids who were just freshly assembled/programmed, and is that really that different from killing child soldiers?
-
Feudalism: maybe look it up in a dictionary or something.
let it be a challenge to you
-
@sao said in An Arx Peeve Thread:
Feudalism: maybe look it up in a dictionary or something.
History is lame. It can teach us nothing.
When someone shows you who they are, over and over again? Believe them.
