Brand MU Day
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Register
    • Login

    Mod Voice

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Comments & Feedback
    79 Posts 21 Posters 3.7k Views
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • PavelP
      Pavel @bear_necessities
      last edited by

      @bear_necessities said in Mod Voice:

      I assume the thread can just get locked, and a separate post can be added with the explanation.

      Eh, depends. I can see plenty of situations where a mod can wade in and be like “okay, calm it down” before things get to the state of needing a lock. I wonder how many hog pit shitfights would’ve cooled to a simmer if someone outside of the situation would come in and say “back to your corners and calm down for a bit.”

      He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
      BE AN ADULT

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
      • farfallaF
        farfalla @Tez
        last edited by

        @Tez Thank you bb but it’s not that big a deal, haha. I was just saying there can be reasons to want to block that don’t make someone un-admin-worthy. I think I fall on the side of just putting ADMIN: before anything. Easy.

        as previously stated, good day.

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
        • IoleRaeI
          IoleRae
          last edited by

          My suggestion for separate accounts is because historically, the community (at large) has had HUGE difficulties telling between. The ‘is that a mod voice?’ was definitely the biggest “thing” that was difficult about modding MSB. It’s the most absolute, obvious way I can think of to remove the point of confusion.

          If folks can be better about other people being able to tell than historic attempts, I think it would be fine. I WILL say the suggestion is not because of the recent dust-ups over there, but instead something I have been advocating for for a long time, just to remove the stupid confusion and take it off the table.

          the entity previously known as Sunny

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
          • glitchG
            glitch
            last edited by

            I very much dislike the idea of a separate mod account. Even with attaching a name, it is false separation and I feel it very easily dilutes accountability.

            Honestly, my first thought is that, to mod, you cannot behave as confrontationally, familiarly or annoyingly as you would as a general community member. I do not mean to say you cannot have opinions, but whether you’re using your main account or some mod exclusive account, you have power on this forum. By accepting the position, I feel you also have a responsibility to act with more decorum. If you cannot accept that, then do not mod. Not because you’re a bad person, but because not everyone is oriented toward what the position requires (obviously just my opinion of the position requirements).

            So my real suggestion is, if you’re a mod and you’re about to post something that is not mod-related, the standard for your tone needs to be higher.

            TezT KarmaBumK G 3 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 8
            • TezT
              Tez Administrators @glitch
              last edited by

              @glitch You’re a good egg and I’M TELLING EVERYONE.

              she/they

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 4
              • KarmaBumK
                KarmaBum @glitch
                last edited by

                @glitch said in Mod Voice:

                Honestly, my first thought is that, to mod, you cannot behave as confrontationally, familiarly or annoyingly as you would as a general community member.

                I was thinking the same thing as I was ruminating on this whole mess this morning.

                . o O ( If I was a mod - no wait, fuck that, i would never mod this community because then i couldn’t have fun there any more… )

                It’s a thankless job. Good luck, guys. ❤

                On Dragon Wings · https://pern.gaslightswitch.com · pern.gaslightswitch.com port 4201

                PavelP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 4
                • G
                  GF @glitch
                  last edited by

                  @glitch said in Mod Voice:

                  I very much dislike the idea of a separate mod account. Even with attaching a name, it is false separation and I feel it very easily dilutes accountability.

                  This is a good point, but at the same time, I worry the insistence on labeling people as mods will subtly ostracize the mods and divorce their interests from users’ as they become the Them to our Us. I’m not sure how accommodate your concern and mine, though. Perhaps instead of dedicated mods, it should be a temporary, rotating position we all take our turns at so we all live in both worlds?

                  P 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                  • P
                    Pyrephox Administrators @GF
                    last edited by

                    @GF Honestly, I don’t see that happening much in this particular community. The users are (as we’ve seen) not likely to put mods on a pedestal or treat them much different. Pre-this current blowup, mods weren’t treated any differently, and I think it was just the personalities involved that had it blow up. None of the current administrators insist on any sort of ‘authority’ - when we act, we’ll tell you why, and take responsibility for it without demanding ORDER AND RESPECT.

                    Aside from the respect I’d like as just a person, of course!

                    G 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 4
                    • PavelP
                      Pavel @KarmaBum
                      last edited by

                      @KarmaBum said in Mod Voice:

                      . o O ( If I was a mod - no wait, fuck that, i would never mod this community because then i couldn’t have fun there any more… )

                      Yeah, this is a growing concern for me as well.

                      He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
                      BE AN ADULT

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                      • farfallaF
                        farfalla
                        last edited by

                        Two thoughts:

                        1. As long as the community has trust in the mods, any decision they make about this will work as long as it’s made with thoughtfulness and intention.
                        2. No mods should ever be making jokes about banning, locking threads, or any other mod power. Even when not in “mod voice”.

                        as previously stated, good day.

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 4
                        • G
                          GF @Pyrephox
                          last edited by

                          @Pyrephox said in Mod Voice:

                          @GF Honestly, I don’t see that happening much in this particular community. The users are (as we’ve seen) not likely to put mods on a pedestal or treat them much different.

                          Rather, I think we have an anti-authoritarian streak strong enough that instead of idolizing mods, we’d be more likely to treat them with suspicion or even hostility. Don’t forget, the comment that prompted mine is one that seemed to be distrustful that if a mod’s name isn’t attached to everything they do, then they will be tempted to deceive and abuse.

                          PavelP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                          • PavelP
                            Pavel @GF
                            last edited by Pavel

                            @GF said in Mod Voice:

                            Don’t forget, the comment that prompted mine is one that seemed to be distrustful that if a mod’s name isn’t attached to everything they do, then they will be tempted to deceive and abuse.

                            In our group chat thing, I raised a similar issue. When we’re setting policy or making decisions like this, I tend to err on the side of “okay, not us obviously, but what about someone else that’s brought on later?” i.e. How is someone else going to try and break this?

                            ETA: And this is partly why we’re asking for your input. The main reason being is that we serve the community, not the other way around, but additionally, it’s just a fact that you trust us for now, but new people may come and old may go, or the novelty of the new forum will wear off and we’ll lose our lustre or something.

                            So setting standards and policies now is a step toward not needing to blindly trust mods/admin so much.

                            He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
                            BE AN ADULT

                            G 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                            • G
                              GF @Pavel
                              last edited by

                              @Pavel I think the site’s owner should be quick to remove such a person from power, not necessarily permanently. Simply removing their power until a public conversation can be had and an agreement reached about the severity of their offense, which might be determined to be no big deal and worth reinstating them, would be a great show of good faith from the bosses.

                              PavelP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                              • PavelP
                                Pavel @GF
                                last edited by

                                @GF said in Mod Voice:

                                I think the site’s owner should be quick to remove such a person from power, not necessarily permanently.

                                That’s the ideal.

                                But we know that’s not a guarantee. The more we put down into actual words and doctrine, as it were, the better.

                                He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
                                BE AN ADULT

                                saoS 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                • saoS
                                  sao @Pavel
                                  last edited by

                                  @Pavel this is true. But fire anyone who ruleslawyers.

                                  let it be a challenge to you

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                  • RozR
                                    Roz
                                    last edited by

                                    Hello, I have returned with a Brand New Opinion, and it is:

                                    Don’t borrow trouble.

                                    Debates around “Mod Voice” on MSB were not actually a common occurrence. The instances I recall tended to center around two mods who at least some part of the community did not feel were a fit for a moderation position because of the way they tended to engage in the board just as users. It meant that the delineation was not as clear because they already had a habit of being in the midst of debates, and because they didn’t really make it clear when they were speaking as mods.

                                    I think this is just – a tonal thing. Treat the moderation end of things with Serious Voice. In my experience, it actually shouldn’t be difficult to tell the difference if there’s any real effort to just – make it apparent.

                                    I dunno. I agree with just not joking about the mod end of things – banning, locking threads, etc. – with the general understanding that lots of users may not know you and your overall joking style. Just joke about other things, use a serious voice when you’re actually forced to moderate, and I think mostly it’ll be fine.

                                    she/her | playlist

                                    PavelP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 11
                                    • PavelP
                                      Pavel @Roz
                                      last edited by

                                      @Roz said in Mod Voice:

                                      Debates around “Mod Voice” on MSB were not actually a common occurrence.

                                      Not publicly, but it had been a personal concern of mine for a while. This is why I brought it up to the others when we started here.

                                      Tone’s hard to read in text, especially if you’re new or just not familiar with the individuals involved. So a clear delineation between user and moderator talk is important, to my mind.

                                      He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
                                      BE AN ADULT

                                      NarsonN 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                                      • NarsonN
                                        Narson @Pavel
                                        last edited by

                                        @Pavel said in Mod Voice:

                                        @Roz said in Mod Voice:

                                        Debates around “Mod Voice” on MSB were not actually a common occurrence.

                                        Not publicly, but it had been a personal concern of mine for a while. This is why I brought it up to the others when we started here.

                                        Tone’s hard to read in text, especially if you’re new or just not familiar with the individuals involved. So a clear delineation between user and moderator talk is important, to my mind.

                                        I think, sadly, the answer might be what Glitch intimated towards. That admins/mods/supreme basilisks/whatever will have to be careful and understand just exactly that. Or err on the side of not posting rather than posting if they feel their engagement would be chilling/misconstrued.

                                        I do think it is a fair point, that even with a single log in there is power in a title attached to a name. That’s human nature.

                                        When someone shows you who they are, over and over again? Believe them.

                                        PavelP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                        • PavelP
                                          Pavel @Narson
                                          last edited by

                                          @Narson said in Mod Voice:

                                          Or err on the side of not posting rather than posting if they feel their engagement would be chilling/misconstrued.

                                          Alas, this is where I fundamentally disagree. I am a member of this community first, an arbiter or whatever second. I plan to engage with this community as I always have, and rely on the rest of the admin/mod team to make judgement calls of situations I’m directly involved in.

                                          That said, us (that is to say the admin/mods) acting like a dick just to act like a dick won’t be tolerated. Making admin/mod calls on debates/arguments/whatever that we’re actively participating in won’t be tolerated.

                                          He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
                                          BE AN ADULT

                                          TezT NarsonN glitchG 3 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                          • TezT
                                            Tez Administrators @Pavel
                                            last edited by

                                            @Pavel said in Mod Voice:

                                            Alas, this is where I fundamentally disagree. I am a member of this community first, an arbiter or whatever second. I plan to engage with this community as I always have, and rely on the rest of the admin/mod team to make judgement calls of situations I’m directly involved in.

                                            That said, us (that is to say the admin/mods) acting like a dick just to act like a dick won’t be tolerated. Making admin/mod calls on debates/arguments/whatever that we’re actively participating in won’t be tolerated.

                                            I just wanna back Pavel up here. We’ve been talking about all of this feedback and thinking about the community you guys are asking for. Right now we are leaning toward NO MOD VOICE and NO MOD ACCOUNT and just–

                                            Being people.

                                            Who act like normal people and use their serious voices when they need to use their serious voices.

                                            One of the things we’ve talked about a lot – haha, just kidding; I’m the community lurker. One of the things OTHER PEOPLE have talked about in threads is that staff on games are people too. And mods on boards are people too. I wouldn’t expect someone to not get engaged in VIGOROUS DEBATE just because they are a mod.

                                            I do, absolutely, expect that someone doesn’t switch hats mid-debate, though. Like Pavel says: don’t make admin calls where you are already involved. That’s bad behavior and has no place here.

                                            WE WILL FORMALIZE SOMETHING, that said, and are still listening to feedback. PLEASE LOOK FORWARD TO OUR F.U.C.K.E.R. or P.E.N.I.S. or whatever questionable acronym we decide on.

                                            she/they

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 5
                                            • First post
                                              Last post