Brand MU Day
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Login

    Character Death

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Game Gab
    101 Posts 23 Posters 1.0k Views
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic was forked from Factions Tez
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • FaradayF
      Faraday @MisterBoring
      last edited by

      @MisterBoring said in Character Death:

      I think it’s odd when people say MUs aren’t TTRPGs, but I could take the rules of almost any MU, print them out and run a tabletop group with them.

      You can play TT with literally any rules or no rules (diceless/freeform) though. Many TT systems are adapted to LARPs too. So yes, they are mostly offshoots of the same family tree, but they are all very different experiences IMHO.

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Third EyeT
        Third Eye @Ashkuri
        last edited by

        @Ashkuri said in Character Death:

        Killing off your beloved character and making yourself and all your friends cry is some of the best fun you can have out here.

        a woman in a plaid shirt is laughing

        I want something else to get me through this
        Semi-charmed kinda life, baby, baby
        I want something else, I'm not listening when you say good-bye

        She/Her or They/Them

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 6
        • JumpscareJ
          Jumpscare @MisterBoring
          last edited by

          @MisterBoring said in Character Death:

          your PC sacrifice ties off an 18 month plot and removes one of the biggest antagonists in the game permanently

          Someone did that in Silent Heaven. The character was absolutely outmatched, but their sacrifice gave the other PCs just enough time to recover and defeat the big bad.

          After the event, I created the “Blaze of Glory” role in Discord just for them. It’s a special tag that has no effect, but it carries a lot of meaning.

          Game-runner of Silent Heaven, a small-town horror MU.
          https://silentheaven.org

          MisterBoringM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 4
          • MisterBoringM
            MisterBoring @Jumpscare
            last edited by

            @Jumpscare I don’t know why people don’t jump at those chances more. If I was running a game and someone had an amazing send off death idea for their character, I’d do everything I can to make it have the impact of the comet in Deep Impact.

            make gifs at gifsoup.com is displayed on the bottom of this image

            Proud Member of the Pro-Mummy Alliance

            PavelP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
            • PavelP
              Pavel @MisterBoring
              last edited by Pavel

              @MisterBoring said in Character Death:

              I don’t know why people don’t jump at those chances more.

              I do. They very rarely appear, and when they do, there’s no guarantee it’ll matter. People want their decisions, and their deaths, to matter. So going out in a blaze of glory is a risk.

              ETA: This is not the reason, but it is a reason. There are likely many.

              He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
              BE AN ADULT

              FaradayF 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
              • FaradayF
                Faraday @Pavel
                last edited by

                @Pavel said in Character Death:

                I do. They very rarely appear, and when they do, there’s no guarantee it’ll matter.

                Good point. Also, it fundamentally prevents me from doing anything else with that character, which as I said above - is pretty much the whole reason I’m there.

                I liken it to how ensemble TV shows rarely kill off their main leads. Occasionally they’ll do it as a shocking twist or something, but mostly they only do it when people leave the show. I realize there are those who prefer the Game of Thrones model where nobody’s safe. They like feeling like the characters are in real peril. It makes the show feel more gritty since the main chars aren’t protected by plot armor.

                And to be clear - there’s nothing wrong with liking that. I’m not trying to wrongfun anyone. All I want is a little non-judgemental understanding that there are those of us who get attached to characters - both in TV and in MUs - and who don’t like having to get invested all over again when they get bumped off randomly.

                PavelP somasatoriS 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 2
                • PavelP
                  Pavel @Faraday
                  last edited by

                  @Faraday There’s also the fact that in order for these blazes of glory to be as impactful as they obviously have been, they have to be rare. If it was the Done Thing™, then they’d just be another MU story trope that we roll our eyes at.

                  I’m not against character’s dying, but I’d rather be Boromir than Ned Stark. But ideally, I’d be Richard Sharpe.

                  He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
                  BE AN ADULT

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                  • somasatoriS
                    somasatori @Faraday
                    last edited by somasatori

                    @Faraday said in Character Death:

                    And to be clear - there’s nothing wrong with liking that. I’m not trying to wrongfun anyone. All I want is a little non-judgemental understanding that there are those of us who get attached to characters - both in TV and in MUs - and who don’t like having to get invested all over again when they get bumped off randomly.

                    I did also want to note that my being pro-character death (or Game of Thrones model) is also not intended to wrongfun anyone else. I think it’s great to get attached to your character. Passion for your hobby is awesome! It sucks to be invested in something and have it taken away and it’s definitely not wrong. IMO, the only “right way” to MUSH is to be an enthusiastic participant and contributor in however you and your friends want to tell a story and in whichever way works best to achieve that goal, so long as it doesn’t hurt anyone else OOC!

                    "And the Fool says, pointing to the invertebrate fauna feeding in the graves: 'Here a monarchy reigns, mightier than you: His Majesty the Worm.'"
                    Italo Calvino, The Castle of Crossed Destines

                    PavelP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                    • AshkuriA
                      Ashkuri
                      last edited by

                      What currently-active MUSHes have a risk of non-consensual character permadeth?

                      Retromux/Numetal I guess? I don’t know of any other ones, and I don’t play that one so I don’t even know if it’s the case there.

                      YamY 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                      • PavelP
                        Pavel @somasatori
                        last edited by

                        @somasatori Agreed. So long as expectations are communicated ahead of time so nobody’s blindsided by being “Suddenly Stark’d”? By all means.

                        He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
                        BE AN ADULT

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                        • MisterBoringM
                          MisterBoring
                          last edited by

                          I think after reading a lot of stuff in this thread, I realize that I don’t necessarily want characters to die, I want characters to have their story end. And I don’t want it to be arbitrary or random. I want staff to be brave enough to say to their players “We want you to tell a complete story.” not “Please write the same character until your fingers rot off.” More games should have a character generation with, “Please include an idea of how you see your character’s story ending in your application.” It doesn’t have to be death, it could be the character realizing they’ve resolved that part of their lives in the region of the world the game takes place in, and getting on a horse and heading to new horizons. I love stories the most when they are complete and then I can move on to creating another new story. When I read, I don’t tend to go for book series that run on and on for 10+ books. I really hate that Brian Herbert is trying to keep Dune going on and on and on. I stopped reading Dresden Files when I realized that Jim Butcher wasn’t planning on ending the series likely anytime ever.

                          In my history of playing these games, if a game that’s been around for a long time seems to have a giant population of dinosaur characters, I’m very likely to avoid even making a character.

                          Proud Member of the Pro-Mummy Alliance

                          FaradayF somasatoriS 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 3
                          • YamY
                            Yam @Ashkuri
                            last edited by

                            @Ashkuri I really can’t think of any. Is non-consensual permadeath actually a thing anymore?

                            Curious if anyone has actually seen a PC death play out where the player certainly didn’t intend to die AND didn’t consent to being in a situation that warned the risk.

                            RozR catzillaC somasatoriS PavelP FaradayF 5 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 1
                            • FaradayF
                              Faraday @MisterBoring
                              last edited by

                              @MisterBoring said in Character Death:

                              I think after reading a lot of stuff in this thread, I realize that I don’t necessarily want characters to die, I want characters to have their story end.

                              Dang, I have the opposite problem in MUs. I have a hard enough time getting my characters’ story arcs to a meaningful conclusion, let alone to bring the entire character to a nice ending.

                              There are exceptions of course. BSP ended in a way that gave everyone a chance to wrap things up and write epilogues. That was nice. TGG’s campaigns had fixed endings, so we could bring things to a natural conclusion.

                              MisterBoringM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                              • somasatoriS
                                somasatori @MisterBoring
                                last edited by somasatori

                                @MisterBoring said in Character Death:

                                I think after reading a lot of stuff in this thread, I realize that I don’t necessarily want characters to die, I want characters to have their story end. And I don’t want it to be arbitrary or random. I want staff to be brave enough to say to their players “We want you to tell a complete story.” not “Please write the same character until your fingers rot off.”

                                Actually, you mentioning this struck me immediately, and I think that’s where I’m going with it too. Every good beginning and middle deserves a good end, which is often not provided to MUSH characters. I do think that the player should be able to decide when that end will be, or that staff might indicate “hey, this plot could include character death/retirement as a possibility as it’s very dangerous” and allow the players to say yea or nay as to whether they participate, but endings are important pieces regardless. This is also super hard to do, as @Faraday illustrated, since it’s hard to know exactly when an ending might be appropriate.

                                In my history of playing these games, if a game that’s been around for a long time seems to have a giant population of dinosaur characters, I’m very likely to avoid even making a character.

                                One of the more frustrating things in the hobby for me is when a game just kind of drags on and on. There might be new stories popping up, but if the majority of the population have been playing their characters for 10+ years, or being honest even 5+ years, I’m going to assume that everything my new PC does will be inconsequential by comparison. The games I’ve had a had in creating, I’ve tried to push an absolute time limit of 3 years. Time-limited MUSHes are probably their own thread, tbh.

                                I’m well aware that this is also due in part to the kinds of games I tend to play. On games that don’t include experience points and stat-based character development, or where stats are not incentivized, the dynamic will be different.

                                "And the Fool says, pointing to the invertebrate fauna feeding in the graves: 'Here a monarchy reigns, mightier than you: His Majesty the Worm.'"
                                Italo Calvino, The Castle of Crossed Destines

                                PavelP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                • PavelP
                                  Pavel @somasatori
                                  last edited by

                                  @somasatori Agreed. And I’d even wager that if a game is designed to be temporary, with an intention of having an ending, then people will be more inclined to have characters who are temporary. Or at least work towards an arc rather than a straight line.

                                  He/Him. Opinions and views are solely my own unless specifically stated otherwise.
                                  BE AN ADULT

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • MisterBoringM
                                    MisterBoring @Faraday
                                    last edited by

                                    @Faraday said in Character Death:

                                    I have a hard enough time getting my characters’ story arcs to a meaningful conclusion, let alone to bring the entire character to a nice ending.

                                    I would not be surprised if the ephemeral life span of most MUs being the major subconscious reason for people being gun shy about working to a fitting story end for their characters.

                                    Proud Member of the Pro-Mummy Alliance

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                    • EvilgraysonE
                                      Evilgrayson @MisterBoring
                                      last edited by

                                      @MisterBoring said in Character Death:

                                      @somasatori said in Factions:

                                      This could be staff-generated or player-generated in the case of player-run factions vs. other player-run factions, but it’s integral to have core people running stories (like in your example with LARPs, you have the GM and assistant GMs) regularly for people to feel like it matters.

                                      What if it was staff generated by finding a few volunteers to play characters who exist solely to add to the story and die to set the example that PC death can be rewarding to the greater story?

                                      I’ve done this. There was a group of us who used to advertise that we’d happily play short-term characters and plot devices, although there weren’t many games who took us up on it.

                                      Best death as a bit part? A police detective in 1920s Chicago whose partner made some dumb calls and got them both killed. The hitman felt so sorry. 🙂

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • MisterBoringM
                                        MisterBoring
                                        last edited by

                                        I wonder if incentivizing character story endings would lead to more characters finding a story ending in games. Staff could offer extra starting XP, or special perks that represent rare story elements for new characters after working out a full story for their current character.

                                        Proud Member of the Pro-Mummy Alliance

                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • RozR
                                          Roz @Yam
                                          last edited by

                                          @Yam said in Character Death:

                                          @Ashkuri I really can’t think of any. Is non-consensual permadeath actually a thing anymore?

                                          Curious if anyone has actually seen a PC death play out where the player certainly didn’t intend to die AND didn’t consent to being in a situation that warned the risk.

                                          I think it depends on how we’re defining things. Because I’d say that non-consensual permadeath would include situations where the players consented to the risk, but still took it, and the dice went how they went. That’s definitely something that still happens on games. Because, to my mind, they still weren’t choosing the PC death.

                                          she/her | playlist

                                          MisterBoringM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                          • MisterBoringM
                                            MisterBoring @Roz
                                            last edited by

                                            @Roz said in Character Death:

                                            Because, to my mind, they still weren’t choosing the PC death.

                                            That’s almost it’s own question in this topic:

                                            Is agreeing to a certain level of risk for a character and then dying in the scene a form of non-consensual permadeath?

                                            Proud Member of the Pro-Mummy Alliance

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                            • First post
                                              Last post