Don’t forget we moved!
https://brandmu.day/
Concordia Thread
-
@KarmaBum said in Concordia: A Lord & Ladies Ares Game:
No, you didn’t. You made a side-handed, presumptive comment rather than address the concern or bring up a question.
I didn’t think I needed to pass it through a UN speechwriter. Sorry not sorry that it didn’t pass your standards. I’m not sure why you’re on my jock so much and feel the need to make snide comments wherever I post, but I meant what I wrote and I meant what I asked.
As others have mentioned, they noticed too. I didn’t even question the policy. Its their game and they can do what they want. I was glad for the clarification though. Apparently, others were too.
My point was that I was surprised that no one else had brought up something that was very noticeable to me and asked was that something that was just common in the genre.
@bear_necessities said in Concordia Thread:
So, you don’t play L&L games but you have a problem with a game you’re not going to play with a genre you don’t even like? LOL why are you here commenting at all, this isn’t even constructive.
I was considering playing it. I came across that in the files while looking into the game, which as I mentioned earlier, looked interesting. I haven’t played those games before, which is why I asked. Because I didn’t know.
It may not be constructive to you, but it is a determining factor to me why the gamerunner needs the leaders of the world have to look like the Aryan master race, without exception.
So I asked if it was a common thing in Lord and Ladies games. If it was, that probably wouldn’t be for me. Racial politics wouldn’t be something I’d enjoy.
No one was hating on the game. Geez Louise.
-
@Warma-Sheen said in Concordia Thread:
It may not be constructive to you, but it is a determining factor to me why the gamerunner needs the leaders of the world have to look like the Aryan master race
@Warma-Sheen said in Concordia Thread:
Racial politics wouldn’t be something I’d enjoy.
See when you say things like ‘Aryan master race’ and go about two steps away from outright calling the gamerunners racist, but then slap on ‘constructive’, it does not make your argument actually constructive.
I didn’t see a single help file that suggeted there was racial politics in this game. I don’t know where you caught that assumption either. Honestly based on the PBs already, this is an encouragingly diverse game and race doesn’t seem to factor into anything except your own head.
-
@bear_necessities said in Concordia Thread:
I didn’t see a single help file that suggeted there was racial politics in this game. I don’t know where you caught that assumption either. Honestly based on the PBs already, this is an encouragingly diverse game and race doesn’t seem to factor into anything except your own head.
Pretty much this. I read through the files for at least an hour and a half yesterday and no where has anything been said about conflict based on how people look. In fact, given the rest of game policy I’m pretty sure anyone coming into the game trying to do just that would be shown the door quickly.
-
I’m just going to be real with you all. I put in a request letting them know I felt awkward about the gods being white, and my non-white noble house worshipping a white patron god. And you know what? They were like, ‘good lookin out, this is on our list of things to review.’ And it made me feel immediately more comfortable.
I don’t think this beef in the comments is in the spirit of the game runners.
-
@helvetica I hadn’t caught that (and I’m glad they’re going to correct), but I have to say that I was THRILLED to see that not every roster character was white and that for houses where POCs are the norm it wasn’t like “and so you love jade and tea obvs.”
-
@helvetica I picked one of the houses of color! I love the fact they are scholars and the wise house! It is very refreshing in my book!
-
Really glad to see there’s so much activity generated by this place! Congratulations, @Tez!
they/them
-
@Warma-Sheen said in Concordia Thread:
@Faraday I think that just means allotting a certain number of xp points to character based on age. Or just granting a chunk of xp to an older character to indicate they have had more experience in their life than younger characters. I don’t think it necessitates code. It is definitely a game decision.
The code does not allow you to set different amounts of starting ability points based on age or any other criteria, and giving them a bucket of extra XP after chargen just won’t work due to spending/saving limits in the XP code.
Sure, you could try to work around the code and manually negotiate/set additional skills, but that undermines the advantages of the quick and easy review/approval system FS3 gives you. It also runs contrary to the design recommendations.
FS3 is designed to let everyone start out awesome. Older people are not inherently more awesome than younger people.
-
@bear_necessities said in Concordia Thread:
See when you say things like ‘Aryan master race’ and go about two steps away from outright calling the gamerunners racist, but then slap on ‘constructive’, it does not make your argument actually constructive.
Which is why I didn’t say that in the post.
@bear_necessities said in Concordia Thread:
I didn’t see a single help file that suggeted there was racial politics in this game. I don’t know where you caught that assumption either. Honestly based on the PBs already, this is an encouragingly diverse game and race doesn’t seem to factor into anything except your own head.
It probably is in my head. I’m sensitive to it. Chalk it up to a lifetime of dealing with racism, overt, subtle, and unconscious. Again, which is why I asked if that were common in these games.
I caught that assumption from the post which stated that while all the houses had a general type or look, characters in the lead house had to be fair skin, blond hair, blue eyes. It was pretty clear that there could be no deviation for how the ruling house characters could look, and implied that the other houses could vary in how they looked, but not the ruling house. The rulers were all going to look this one specific, very White way. And all other characters of color were exclusively limited to lesser houses.
What I do know of L&L games is that there are house politics. But if you racially limit houses to specific looking races then you’re just calling racial politics a different name: house politics.
It gave me pause.
This was very WTF to me but I noticed no one else seemed to be bothered by this very obvious racial caste system. So I didn’t even question the system itself, I just asked if this was a common thing on these types of games.
The game runner came on and explained it.
Deal was done. It was simply an in game storyline gimmick.
That just wasn’t where my head went at all when I saw that. Is that just in my head? Sure. Say it was. I’m okay with that. My experiences are my experiences. They are valid, as are my questions.
-
@Faraday said in Concordia Thread:
Older people are not inherently more awesome than younger people.
Could you tell that to every Boomer comedian, please? Thank you.
@Warma-Sheen said in Concordia Thread:
That just wasn’t where my head went at all when I saw that
I try my best, these days, to go for cock-up over conspiracy. Don’t assume malice until you’ve probed a bit to see what’s going on.
-
@somasatori I didn’t do nothin’! All I did was split the thread. The work on this is all @Whisky and team.
she/they
-
@Tez OH! Well, there’s egg on my face.
Congratulations to @Whisky and their team, then! Always good to see enthusiasm in new games as they come up, but it’s an even better feeling when people validate the work you put into something by really engaging and vibing with your setting.
-
@Pavel said in Concordia Thread:
@Warma-Sheen said in Concordia Thread:
That just wasn’t where my head went at all when I saw that
I try my best, these days, to go for cock-up over conspiracy. Don’t assume malice until you’ve probed a bit to see what’s going on.
You’re right. And I tried. The probing was what people seemed to take offense to, or the way I went about it.
The actual issue was resolved within minutes, but the rest dragged on a bit longer.
-
@KarmaBum said in Concordia Thread:
Thanks for getting that out of the way for all zero people who were hung up about it.
Indeed. For the record, I’m to some degree one of those zero people and I can safely say I’m glad it was brought up and discussed/clarified.
I have enough hobbies where surprise eugenicists/race theory kooks like to sneak in through the door and this sort of thing tends to flush them out. It’s nice to know who you’re dealing with and who you’re not and frankly, this is a valid thing to ask questions about and doesn’t automatically default to finger-pointing and witch-hunting.
-
@helvetica I’m glad to see this, and their response. I actually had also taken a look at the game, and things like this felt icky. But it sounds like it was unintentional and the game runners are doing what they can to listen.
-
@Anhedonia said in Concordia Thread:
@Whisky Good luck bud happy to see things taking off.
Thank you, really do mean it. A lot of the work you did into LA really helped understand the workload, the world, and how to create a place where people feel the creativity to tell their stories.
@bear_necessities said in Concordia Thread:
Anyway @Whisky and @spes good luck, have fun, don’t listen to the haters who aren’t going to play your game anyway
Thank you as well!
@somasatori said in Concordia Thread:
Congratulations to @Whisky and their team, then! Always good to see enthusiasm in new games as they come up, but it’s an even better feeling when people validate the work you put into something by really engaging and vibing with your setting.
Appreciate it as does @spes as well who spent a lot of time making things absolutely amazing looking, written, and thought out.
Current Projects:
Twitch -> https://www.twitch.tv/dukewhisky
-
THE FIRST STAFF RUN PLOT SCENE WAS AMAZING! AS a very well-controlled and well-paced large scene, with something for everyone to do! SO PUMPED FOR MORE!
(Edit:Clarify better)
-
@BloodAngel They did a really good job on this, considering how many people were there. The pacing was perfect and gave people enough time to pose their reaction/actions between GM poses.
I was really impressed with how it was handled. Usually scenes that big take hours and are exhausting/not much fun.
-
I’m trying to sort out how to write this, because I don’t want anyone thinking this is meant to be negative(it’s not), but it is my initial thoughts after letting it sit for a night. Because I was kind of at a loss to how the whole thing was handled.
From a GM perspective, I’m trying to understand the decisions and why where they made. Is it just alpha? Was there not a lot of faith in FS3 as it currently stands on game? Were the NPCs not ready? How is damage and wounds going to be handled? Were healers going to be able to actually heal instead of simply RPing it?
I had written out a whole diatribe on my thoughts and giving feedback, but I feel as if it’s better used as a +request, since feedback was asked for. And I’ll leave that for staff to read rather than putting that all here.
I’ll say this much; I believe staff have the very best intentions, but it almost felt like they were making things far more difficult on themselves than they needed to. Using FS3, and breaking the event into two scenes of combatants and non-coms would’ve likely have made the whole thing more manageable.
But deciding to do manual rolls and math to determine combat? Seeing that took me back to PennMUSH games cira 2005. As far as I could tell(and I could certainly be wrong)everything that I saw happen in that scene could’ve been represented with various different commands in FS3.
I am glad that everyone had a good time with it, but I kind of found it very chaotic and confusing.
I don't know what I'm doing. Poke at Seven Nations sevennations.aresmush.com port 2021
-
@Testament I think that there’s still work going on behind the scenes to try and balance weapons and armor for FS3 combat. I could be way off base of course, but that’s the impression I’ve gotten. I can’t fault them for that, it IS Alpha so now is the time to tweak and tweak and tweak and I’m not sure a BIG PC combat in a BIG GM scene is the best time to test and tweak the system.
But I get where you’re coming from and they do want feedback so for sure send in that request.
