Numetal/Retromux
-
@MisterBoring Absolutely don’t do a three strike system for blatant, overt, and purposeful flouting of rules like that. Like, at most give the player one single warning.
But the real answer is the first option: ban them. There’s absolutely no need to entertain that sort of OOC sneakery.
-
@Roz Agreed. If there is some particular reason that you think they accidentally made an alt (I can’t even think of a reason that might happen, but who knows…), wipe all but one character and tell them that they just got their one and only warning. Otherwise, it’s a flagrant violation of a clear-cut rule: ban, explain, and move on.
Formerly known as Seraphim73 (he/him)
-
@MisterBoring If someone chooses to break a game’s rules, they are uninvited from the game. It’s not hard.
-
@Muscle-Car said in Numetal/Retromux:
Lots of points of failure led to it but it was universally avoidable if any one of the balances had worked.
I feel like this sentence describes the world we’re living in.
-
Naturally, make sure the player is actually breaking the rule first. Perhaps make mention of some mechanism for people living in the same house to have that fact (and the characters they play) registered somewhere so that all the staff know that any IP similarities have already been accounted for.
I imagine it’s fairly obvious when that mechanism is being misused.
@Roadspike said in Numetal/Retromux:
If there is some particular reason that you think they accidentally made an alt (I can’t even think of a reason that might happen, but who knows…)
The only reason I can think of is if you create a character, get into CG, and get distracted by something shiny and forget about it. Then you come back some time later and don’t recall you’ve ever been there, and make another character. In this instance it should be easy to tell, the other character is old and still in CG.
-
@Pavel said in Numetal/Retromux:
@Gashlycrumb Requiem for Kingsmouth had a thing where you’d have to specifically “apply” for tiers of characters
Yeah. You could have people apply, you could require that they have a trusted existing player as a ‘sponsor’ to get a ‘Main’ character.
It might be a good solution to go with your population-control idea – if you open with a hard limit on how many PCs, then you’re likely to end up with only 1/3 that number in three months and it’ll be hard to recover 'cause the ones who got turned away are not terribly likely to come back. If you have a hard limit on ‘Main’ characters you can upgrade ‘Supporting’ ones and probably have less of a crash problem.
@MisterBoring said in Numetal/Retromux:
So assuming a game has a “no-alts” policy, what’s the ideal response for when a player breaks that rule? I had two ideas, one harsh and one not.
Just ban them.
There’s nothing harsh about it, really. “One character per player” is not a rule that’s open to interpretation.
I am regularly bemused about clear violations of clear rules being repeatedly tolerated, or people getting endless ‘strikes’ after said rule has been clarified. I’ve seen a player continue for a year with a habit of changing the subject any time somebody rolls to eavesdrop on their IC conversation, with other players calling staff and Cheaty-Cheaty Bang-Bang getting the lecture, and then doing it again a week later. I’ve had a staffer tell me they gave an insufferably rude player The Lecture, problem solved, and then just ignore it when I replied that rude player was doing it again right as staffer was assuring me that it wouldn’t happen again. It’s not harsh to stop people who make a habit of breaking the rules or ignore really clear and plain rules.
In over thirty years of playing these damn things I have been banned once, and it was, as far as I could tell, for asking another player for their contact info and explaining that I was gonna quit since Staffer had made clear their intention to exclude me indefinitely. I’ve been threatened with banning for telling a staffer that it “felt railroady” to not be allowed to attempt a con that NPCs were already doing. The recent actual banning that had me raising eyebrows was for the hideous crime of paging people asking for RP when those people wanted to avoid the pager but did not want to go so far as to ask the pager not to contact them. That shit is harsh.
.
"This is Liberty Hall; you can spit on the mat and call the cat a bastard!"
– A. Bertram Chandler -
@Roz said in Numetal/Retromux:
@MisterBoring Absolutely don’t do a three strike system for blatant, overt, and purposeful flouting of rules like that. Like, at most give the player one single warning.
But the real answer is the first option: ban them. There’s absolutely no need to entertain that sort of OOC sneakery.
Doing anything else will encourage some people to do it until they get caught, knowing they had a freebie.
-
@Roadspike I am trying to imagine how you could accidentally make an alt.
Like… I make characters pretty easily but it’s a volitional act.
let it be a challenge to you
-
@sao The same way you accidentally sleep with your partner’s best friend. You slip and fall face first onto ‘create “Alt Character” %PASSWORD%’.
-
@sao said in Numetal/Retromux:
I am trying to imagine how you could accidentally make an alt.
I will admit I have done this once. Here are the details:
This was around 2013 and I honestly don’t remember what game it was (if you happened to be staff there, and recall this, HI!). I was off sick from work, and sitting at my computer delirious from fever and I decided to join a new game. I check it out as a guest, look at their wiki, decide on a concept and then build a character, all while under the effects of OTC cold medicine and general malaise. I submit the character for approval, which required an email address to be associated with the bit, log off of the game, and end up falling asleep while watching Lost In Space.
I promptly in my sleep forget about the character and end up staying in bed with the flu for 2 more days, during which, my initial character gets approved without any changes needed. When I finally get over my flu and sit back down at my computer, I decide to find a new game to play and pick the same game from when I was sick. It doesn’t even dawn on me that there’s a reason I have the game saved in my MU Client. I create an entirely new character from scratch, submit it for approval with the same email address, and almost immediately get a page from staff, “Hey, are you sure you want an alt already? You haven’t even RPed with your first character since they were approved.”
I immediately felt so embarrassed about the situation that I logged off and ghosted that game without playing either character.
-
@Gashlycrumb said in Numetal/Retromux:
In over thirty years of playing these damn things I have been banned once, and it was, as far as I could tell, for asking another player for their contact info and explaining that I was gonna quit since Staffer had made clear their intention to exclude me indefinitely. I’ve been threatened with banning for telling a staffer that it “felt railroady” to not be allowed to attempt a con that NPCs were already doing. The recent actual banning that had me raising eyebrows was for the hideous crime of paging people asking for RP when those people wanted to avoid the pager but did not want to go so far as to ask the pager not to contact them. That shit is harsh.
Actually, Scarpia, I banned you for being a psychic vampire who tested the patience of various players within and outside of your sphere. The reasons why you might have drawn the wrong conclusion is because you were paging people constantly bitching about the game and they told me that you were a gigantic fucking buzz kill and they were avoiding you. Funnily enough it’s essentially the same reason that retro banned Ryen: what’d they say again? “When everyone is avoiding you it’s time to go”?
-
-
@sao I was trying to come up with a situation too, but I couldn’t. I did want to leave the door open, because there are very few things I want to be an absolutist about.
I could imagine something like the delirium situation @MisterBoring mentioned, or it being a month or two in between creating a character you never played and creating a new character because you forgot about the first one, or getting so excited about the concept that you forgot that there were no alts allowed and submitted a new character.
But the response to Staff going, “Um… hold on a sec” would be very telling, and would decide if I went scorched earth or just nuked all but one character and gave them a warning.
-
@Roadspike said in Numetal/Retromux:
But the response to Staff going, “Um… hold on a sec” would be very telling, and would decide if I went scorched earth or just nuked all but one character and gave them a warning.
My response in my situation was literally:
-
Whoops, @Gashlycrumb I was out somewhere doin’ thangs and forgot to evidentiate what i’m talking about.
You’re Scarpia, here’s how i know,
Took me a minute to find it because I forgot I blocked you the day I banned you because you never respond to boundaries with “OK”, you’d respond to them with fucking Atlas Shrugged. That’s the problem. You wouldn’t leave people alone.
et cetera. And this is what I can find by half-ass looking for your screen name on Discord while I’m on vacation. I wonder what is actually on my harddrive at home. Point is, no, nobody is ever banned for one tiny little harmless incident. You got banned due to a larger pattern of behavior of repeatedly sandbagging people who didn’t want contact with you.
The line you say of “but did not want to go so far as to ask the pager not to contact them” is just shifting responsibility onto others for not spelling it out for you instead of acknowledging your behavior was draining and unwelcome. And in fact, I think I did spell it out for you, repeatedly, but since I don’t have access to logs since i’m not home, whatever, let’s say I didn’t. You’re still shifting responsibility onto others for not spelling it out, instead of acknowledging your behavior was draining and unwelcome.
